T. J. Nevin's prisoner photograph of William RYAN at 1983 exhibitions

T. J. NEVIN: exhibition of mugshots at Port Arthur 1983
ERRORS in the TMAG database 2015 re T. J. NEVIN's mugshots
Duplicates, copies and prints of 1870s mugshots

The Mugshot
The press described William Ryan as "respectably attired" in September 1870 at his appearance in court on charges of forgery. They also reported that he was someone who showed deep emotions when given sentence, and someone even prone to dissembling, fakery and over-acting. Care for his personal appearance was not attenuated by a prison sentence, it seems. When Thomas J. Nevin photographed Ryan for police and prison records at the Hobart Gaol during Ryan's six years of incarceration, the resulting photograph showed a clean shaven, nicely groomed and neatly dressed man in a prisoner's uniform, someone with a quiet and self-contained demeanour all round.



Prisoner William Ryan, "60" numbered on front under image in 1983 for removal to PAHS
Photographed by T. J. Nevin 1874
TMAG Collection Ref: Q15576, formerly from the QVMAG collection



Verso inscriptions: NEVIN, T. J. 1874, "60" - noted as the photographer in 1983 when removed from the QVMAG for exhibition at the Port Arthur Historic Site
"248" William Ryan per City of Hobart, number and inscription ca. 1890s-1900s by Beattie et al for exhibition and sale
Torn paper shows removal from the prisoner's criminal record sheet ca. 1916
Photographed by T. J. Nevin 1874
TMAG Collection Ref: Q15576

VERSO NOTES:
Between February and April 1983 a selection of 70 cdv's from John Watt Beattie's collection of 1870s mugshots, which were acquired by the QVMAG Launceston in  the 1930s from his estate, were removed and exhibited at the Port Arthur prison site south of Hobart for the Port Arthur Conservation and Development Project (PACDP). T. J. Nevin's cdv of William Ryan's was numbered "60" under the image on the front, and labelled with Nevin's name, the date he took Ryan's photograph, 1874, and the number "60" on verso, inscribed by QVMAG staff (Wishart et al) to keep track of this cdv and the 70 or so in the removal from Launceston to Port Arthur, south of Hobart.

Those numbers written on the front of these cdv's do not correspond to the original numbers written on the versos by Beattie in the early 1900s when he arranged them at his "Port Arthur Museum" in Hobart for exhibitions and sale, whether to tourists extending their visit to the ruins of the Port Arthur prison or to those seeking family ancestors with a criminal history. Clearly, Thomas J. Nevin's accreditation as the photographer of these 1870s mugshots on display was known and well-documented by 1983. After the exhibition, 50 or so of those cdv's exhibited at Port Arthur in 1983 were not returned to Beattie's collection at the QVMAG, they were deposited instead at the TMAG in Hobart. The list of 200 cdv's drawn up in the 1980s with these new numbers recto as QVMAG property shows 127 were missing, dispersed to national and state libraries, museums and even publishers, and 72 were remaining. The list can be viewed here.

Press reports: William Ryan "wholesale forger"
No history as a transported convict prior to 1856 has surfaced for William Ryan. He arrived at the port of Hobart Town on the steamer the City of Hobart as a passenger in steerage, February 21st 1862.



Ryan, William
Record Type: Arrivals
Title: Mr
Arrival date: 21 Feb 1862
Departure port: Melbourne
Ship: City of Hobart
Record ID: NAME_INDEXES:1532244
Link: https://libraries.tas.gov.au/Digital/MB2-39-1-28/MB2-39-1-28P011

He was tried for uttering a forged cheque at Launceston on 29th December 1868 and sentenced to two years' imprisonment. Within months of discharge, he was arrested and sentenced at the Hobart Supreme Court to ten years' imprisonment for uttering forged cheques. The newspapers of the day took pleasure in reporting the ingenuity of the police in catching him, and the antics of the prisoner in the dock at the Police Court before His Worship the Mayor.

Mercury, Tuesday 27th September 1870
POLICE COURT
Monday, September 20th 1870
Before His Worship the Mayor.
Forgery:- William Ryan was placed in the dock on three charges of forgery, viz. - First, for having on the 5th of September forged a cheque for  £5.12s. bearing the name of John McDermott, and passed it on Mr. W. F. Brownell, draper, of Liverpool-street; secondly , with having on the 17th of September forged and uttered a cheque bearing the name of John Swain for £3.10s. on Mr Winch, grocer, of Davey-street; and thirdly, with forging and uttering a cheque on Mr. Thomas Downey for £4.10s.
The police asked for the accused to be remanded till the 28th of September. Remanded accordingly.
Mercury, Tuesday 27th September 1870
Forgery Case:- A man named William Ryan, recently released from a two years' incarceration, was placed in the dock at the Police Court yesterday, charged with forging three cheques for £5.12s., £3.10s., and   £4.10s respectively, all of which he had succeeded in getting cashed at various business places in Hobart Town. The first cheque was cashed by an assistant of Mr. Brownell, draper, of Liverpool-street, on the 5th of September, since which time, up to Saturday last, the police have been vainly endeavouring to unearth the forger. On Saturday last, however, between the hours of five and six o'clock in the evening, these efforts were rewarded with success. Detective Vickers, accompanied by Sergeant Waller, at the time mentioned happening to be standing near the corner of Harrington and Liverpool-street, observed a man come out of Mr. McCormack's drapery shop, carrying some carpenter's tools. Directly the man caught sight of the constables he began to make off very rapidly, and in his haste dropped one of the tools he had been carrying. Detective Vickers sang out to him that he had dropped something, which only had the effect of quickening the man's pace. This aroused the detective's suspicions, and he ran into Mr. McCormack's shop, and ascertained from him that the man had endevoured to pass a cheque, which he (Mr. McCormack) had refused to accept. Preparations were then made for a capture, Detective Vickers going one way and Sergeant Waller another, so as to hedge the suspicious individual in, and to prevent his escape. This proved successful, for after a run of about a mile and a half, he was brought to bay, and conveyed to the watchhouse. On searching him, several £1 notes and a cheque for £3.10s., which he had been unable to get cashed, were found on him. The charge was not proceeded with yesterday, as the police, for certain reasons, asked for a remand till Wednesday, the 28th inst, which request was granted.
Mercury, Thursday 29th September 1870:
A Wholesale Forger:- William Ryan, a middle-aged, respectably attired man, was placed in the prisoners dock at the Police Court yesterday, on three distinct charges of forgery. The evidence in each case was of the most conclusive character, and left not the shadow of a doubt as to the guilt of the accused, who was accordingly committed to take his trial at the next Criminal Sessions, which commence in Hobart Town on the 22nd November next. Though the prisoner had only recently been liberated from Port Arthur from serving a sentence for a similar offence, he affected to be very much hurt as the position in which he found himself, turning his back on the people in court, and hiding his face in his hands, and when asked to sign his name in the usual way to the commitment paper, he professed his inability to sign his name. The extraordinary spectacle of a forger unable to write caused a smile. The acting was overdone.



Source: THE MERCURY. (1870, September 29). The Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), p. 2. Retrieved July 12, 2015, from https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8863771

An extended account was also published in the Mercury on 29th September 1870, page 3, with detailed depositions from witnesses, and Superintendent Propsting conducting the case.
https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-page785165

Mercury, Saturday 19th November 1870.
SUPREME COURT CRIMINAL SITTINGS.
The session of Oyer and Terminer and General Gaol Delivery will commence on Tuesday next at 11. a.m., at the Court House, Campbell-Street, before Mr. Justice Dobson. A second Court will be presided over by the Chief Justice. The following is the calendar.
Eliza Osborne, wounding
William Ryan, uttering
Joseph Winters, unlawfully wounding
Francis Thomas Allison, wounding
William Triffett, forgery and uttering [etc]

Mercury, Thursday 24th November 1870
SENTENCE
William Ryan was placed in the dock to receive sentence for committing forgery. When asked if he had anything to say why sentence should not be passed on him, he said he hoped His Honor would temper mercy with justice as before committing the forgeries he had endeavoured to get assistance from Government to enable him to go to Launceston, where he had a wife and two children, and where he had left his tools. He had been unsuccessful in that endeavour, and he tried to get money by forgery.
His Honor, addressing the prisoner, said on examination he found that he (the prisoner) had been in the colony about two years. Shortly after his arrival he was sentenced to two years' imprisonment for forgery; and before he had been out of custody many weeks he again committed forgery. He (the judge) could not accept the prisoner's statement as to his endeavouring to obtain relief from Government before he committed the forgery as extenuating the crime in the slightest degree. The maximum punishment for forgery allowed by the law was imprisonment for life, but he (the judge) would not sentence him to the full extent allowed by law, but would order him to be imprisoned for a term that would give him time for reflection.
The sentence, which he considered it his duty to inflict, was that he (the prisoner) be imprisoned for a period of ten years.
The prisoner, who seemed deeply affected, was then removed. The court then rose.
Source: LAW INTELLIGENCE. (1870, November 24). The Mercury (Hobart, Tas. : 1860 - 1954), p. 2. Retrieved July 12, 2015, from https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article8872576

In denial: the TMAG database notes
Does the public need the opinions of museum and library cataloguists which go well beyond basic documented fact? Their so-called "research" which often appears accompanying old photographs may mislead, and in some cases, deliberately so, as this TMAG catalogue reference for T. J. Nevin's photograph of William Ryan demonstrates.



Verso inscriptions: NEVIN, T. J. 1874, "60"
"248" William Ryan per City of Hobart
Photographed by T. J. Nevin 1874
TMAG Collection Ref: Q15576

This print was one of 4 duplicates produced by Nevin for police and prison records
A copy was either removed from the prisoner's rap sheet ca. 1916 by Beattie et al, or pasted to cardboard with 13 similar mugshots for display at Beattie's museum.



CALLOUTS: This is the database information for Thomas J. Nevin's photograph of William Ryan at the Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery (received here in 2015). Even though T. J. Nevin's name and date of photographic capture was clearly written on the verso in 1983, the cataloguist not only chose to ignore it, she wrongly transcribed Nevin's second initial "J" as "S", despite all prior research, publications and exhibitions of these Tasmanian mugshots in Nevin's name throughout the 20th century.

No reference is given for the source of misinformation concerning A. H. Boyd. Note the use of existential sentence structure: "It is thought ...is known to have ..." which suggests objectivity, even common knowledge, when in fact the only source is the TMAG's own publication of an A-Z directory called Tasmanian photographers 1840-1940 (Long, C.; Winter, G. 1995), where the furphy about A. H. Boyd was included as a "belief" purely in the interests of promoting tourism to Port Arthur. In preparing the database notes, the TMAG cataloguist added a few more imaginative flourishes, viz:

1. "keen amateur" ... A.H. Boyd was not a photographer, keen, amateur or otherwise. No photographic works exist by A. H. Boyd in public collections, nor have his descendants proffered or published a single photograph they can claim to be taken by A. H. Boyd from private collections.

2. "room .. studio ... darkroom" ... The so-called "room" at Port Arthur was the Officer's Library established in 1866 by the previous commandant James Boyd and used as a studio by visiting photographers Alfred Bock (1866), Samuel Clifford (1873) and Thomas Nevin (1872-1874).

3. "instructions given to Boyd to photograph the convicts" ... The claim that a document held at the State Library of NSW refers to instructions given to Commandant James Boyd's successor at Port Arthur, A. H. Boyd (1871-1873) to photograph prisoners is incorrect. No such document exists. The so-called "document" in question is nothing more than cargo lists of photographic materials sent to Port Arthur for use by contractors Samuel Clifford and Thomas J. Nevin in 1873 at the request of Parliament to photograph the neglected buildings, the theft of timber, fallow paddocks and surrounding deforestation, all due entirely to A. H. Boyd's corrupt activities. Boyd was not a photographer. He was not the photographer of police mugshots dating from the 1870s which found their way into public collections. Speculation to the contrary is a waste of time and effort, and potentially fraudulent. Instead of wasting time doing so-called "research", cataloguists in museums and libraries would better serve the public by digitising and placing online the RECTO and the VERSO of photographs, and nothing more. The public will do the rest.

Police and Court Records for William RYAN



Name: Ryan, William
Record Type: Convicts
Arrival date:1 Jan 1868
Remarks: Free. Tried Launceston Dec 1868
Index number:61849
Document ID:NAME_INDEXES:1431630 (TAHO)
Conduct Record CON37/1/10 Page 5773

William Ryan was served a two-year sentence handed down on 29th December 1868 at Launceston. He was sent to Port Arthur from where he was "liberated" in 1870. For his second sentence of ten years, he was listed in the Hobart Supreme Court calendar for trial on Tuesday, 22nd November 1870. Whether he was sent back to Port Arthur or remained at the Hobart Gaol is not clear. There is no inscription such as the erroneous "Taken at Port Arthur 1874" on the verso of his photograph. The phrase was devised by Beattie et al to sell these cdv's to tourists in the late 1890s, and does not reflect the criminal history of each prisoner. William Ryan's name does not appear on the Port Arthur conduct registers for 1868 to 1876. His name is also missing from the list tabled in Parliament in July 1873 of prisoners sent to Port Arthur and subsequently relocated to the Hobart Gaol by 1874. William Ryan was already at the Hobart Gaol in 1874 when Thomas Nevin took his photograph for police registers and prison records.



Rough Calendar Hobart Supreme Court, 29th November 1870.
Supreme Court Records, TAHO Ref: GD70-1-1

Mercury, Saturday 19th November 1870.

SUPREME COURT CRIMINAL SITTINGS. The session of Oyer and Terminer and General Gaol Delivery will commence on Tuesday next at 11. a.m., at the Court House, Campbell-Street, before Mr. Justice Dobson. A second Court will be presided over by the Chief Justice. The following is the calendar. Eliza Osborne, wounding William Ryan, uttering Joseph Winters, unlawfully wounding Francis Thomas Allison, wounding William Triffett, forgery and uttering



Source: Tasmania Reports of Crime Information for Police. J. Barnard, Gov't printer.

William Ryan was discharged from the Hobart Gaol in the week ending 3rd May 1876, residue of sentence remitted. He was described as 49 yrs old, dark brown hair, 5'5" tall.

The original Hobart Gaol book print
This print from Thomas J. Nevin's original glass negative was probably one of the originals pasted to Ryan's criminal record sheet on his discharge which was then bound as the Hobart Gaol record book for 1874-1876, mysteriously missing now its original photographs (TAHO holdings). The TMAG item (at top) which is a full-carte-de-visite, probably one of Nevin's stand-alone duplicates, is in fair condition, and not greatly reproduced through scanning (2015), while this version (below) which is held at the State Library of Tasmania is in overall better condition, and has been digitized through photographic reproduction. Note that this print does not bear the number "60" on the mount, which further suggests it was removed more recently from the Hobart Gaol photo book, while the TMAG item, which was originally held at the Queen Victoria Museum and Art Gallery as part of convictaria collector John Watt Beattie's estate, was removed in 1983 for an exhibition at Port Arthur, where it was exposed to air, frequent handling, poor storage, and finally, deposited at the TMAG instead of being returned to the QVMAG.



Tasmanian Archives and Heritage Office
William Ryan, prisoner carte removed from the criminal record sheet
Photographed by T. J. Nevin 1874
TAHO Ref: PH30_1_3262

RELATED POSTS main weblog
First published on
Categories & Tags: , , , ,